Mobile Menu

Top 100 Non-Premier Comics & Graphic Novels: 2012

Peter Gabriel -- MirrorballThe classic pulp heroes, including the Green Hornet, Kato, and The Shadow, joined forces to take down a criminal government in Chris Roberson and Alex Ross' pulp crossover event Masks #1 from Dynamite Entertainment, the best-selling Non-Premier comic book to retailers in 2012. In total, Dynamite had three of the year's top ten Non-Premier comics; Masks #1 was followed by The Shadow #1 at #2 and the Edgar Rice Burroughs adaptation Lord of the Jungle #1 at #9.

The Valiant heroes returned in 2012 and Valiant Entertainment took three spots in the top ten — X-O Manowar #1 ranked #3, Harbinger #1 ranked #4, and Bloodshot #1 ranked #5.

BOOM! Studios rounded out the top ten for 2012 with four titles. From their all-ages KaBOOM! imprint, Adventure Time #1 ranked #6, Adventure Time #2 ranked #7, and Adventure Time: Marceline and the Scream Queens #1 ranked #10. Also from BOOM! Studios, Fanboys Vs. Zombies #1 ranked #8.

Alan Moore and Kevin O'Neill's The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen III: Century #3: 2009, the conclusion to the century-spanning trilogy, from Top Shelf Productions was the year's best-selling Non-Premier Graphic Novel. Also in the top ten from Top Shelf was Jeff Lemire's original graphic novel The Underwater Welder at #7.

BOOM! Studios' Adventure Time Volume 1, the collected edition of the first four issues of their best-selling comic book, ranked #2 for the year.

Dynamite Entertainment had three titles in the top ten, all from Garth Ennis and Darick Robertson's The Boys — Volume 10, Butcher, Baker, Candlestickmaker, ranked #3; Volume 11, Over the Hill with the Swords of a Thousand Men, ranked #4; and Volume 12, The Bloody Doors Off, ranked #8.

Oni Press began reprinting Bryan Lee O'Malley's Scott Pilgrim in color hardcover editions in 2012, and the first volume, Scott Pilgrim's Precious Little Life, ranked #5 for the year.

Legendary Comics' The Tower Chronicles: Geisthawk Volume 1, a supernatural thriller from Matt Wagner (Grendel) and Simon Bisley (Lobo) ranked #8.

Bantam Books' A Game of Thrones Volume 1, a hardcover collection of the first six issues of Dynamite's adaptation of George R.R. Martin's fantasy novel A Game of Thrones, ranked #9.

Finally, Kodansha Comics' Sailor Moon Volume 3 ranked #10 for the year. Additionally, this book was the year's top-selling Manga.

TOP 100 NON-PREMIER COMICS
Based on Total Unit Sales of Products Invoiced in Calendar Year 2012

QTY
RANK
OVERALL
QTY
RANK
OVERALL
DOLLAR
RANK
ITEM CODE DESCRIPTION PRICE VENDOR
1 196 107 SEP120970-M MASKS #1 $3.99 DE
2 418 251 MAR128302-M SHADOW #1 $3.99 DE
3 440 268 JUN128136-M X-O MANOWAR #1 $3.99 VAL
4 767 485 AUG128057-M HARBINGER #1 $3.99 VAL
5 878 590 AUG128396-M BLOODSHOT #1 $3.99 VAL
6 893 518 JAN128109-M ADVENTURE TIME #1 $3.99 BOO
7 1007 609 JAN128240-M ADVENTURE TIME #2 $3.99 BOO
8 1011 2454 FEB128242-M FANBOYS VS ZOMBIES #1 $1.00 BOO
9 1028 2591 OCT110967 LORD OF THE JUNGLE #1 (MR) $1.00 DE
10 1032 728 MAY120990-M ADVENTURE TIME MARCELINE SCREAM QUEENS #1 $3.99 BOO
11 1042 755 JUN121322-M ARCHER & ARMSTRONG #1 $3.99 VAL
12 1047 723 FEB120869 ADVENTURE TIME #3 $3.99 BOO
13 1074 848 APR120950 ADVENTURE TIME #5 $3.99 BOO
14 1096 821 SEP121219-M SHADOWMAN #1 $3.99 VAL
15 1121 890 MAR120884 ADVENTURE TIME #4 $3.99 BOO
16 1131 859 JUL121254-M X-O MANOWAR #5 $3.99 VAL
17 1133 847 MAY120994 ADVENTURE TIME #6 $3.99 BOO
18 1154 2997 OCT120874-M DEATHMATCH #1 $1.00 BOO
19 1164 878 MAY128153-M X-O MANOWAR #2 $3.99 VAL
20 1165 897 MAY128165-M SHADOW #2 $3.99 DE
21 1222 934 JUN120949 ADVENTURE TIME #7 $3.99 BOO
22 1223 940 SEP120936-M ADVENTURE TIME #10 $3.99 BOO
23 1263 959 AUG120938 ADVENTURE TIME #9 $3.99 BOO
24 1267 957 JUL120908 ADVENTURE TIME #8 $3.99 BOO
25 1338 3241 MAR128272-M HIGHER EARTH #1 $1.00 BOO
26 1343 1013 NOV120957 ADVENTURE TIME FIONNA & CAKE #1 $3.99 BOO
27 1344 1011 APR121003 SHADOW #3 $3.99 DE
28 1389 1068 MAY121315 X-O MANOWAR #3 $3.99 VAL
29 1401 1085 MAY121021 SHADOW #4 $3.99 DE
30 1427 1099 AUG128058-M HARBINGER #2 $3.99 VAL
31 1439 3363 APR128253-M EXTERMINATION #1 $1.00 BOO
32 1459 1121 JUN120946 ADVENTURE TIME MARCELINE SCREAM QUEENS #2 $3.99 BOO
33 1484 1143 JUL120905 ADVENTURE TIME MARCELINE SCREAM QUEENS #3 $3.99 BOO
34 1500 1158 JUN121017 SHADOW #5 $3.99 DE
35 1510 1428 MAY121361-M WONDERLAND #1 (MR) $2.99 ZEN
36 1513 1162 JUN121330 X-O MANOWAR #4 $3.99 VAL
37 1519 1173 SEP128334-M BRAVEST WARRIORS #1 $3.99 BOO
38 1526 1174 AUG120935 ADVENTURE TIME MARCELINE SCREAM QUEENS #4 $3.99 BOO
39 1551 1209 NOV110933 BOYS #62 (MR) $3.99 DE
40 1555 1195 AUG128397-M BLOODSHOT #2 $3.99 VAL
41 1558 973 SEP120975 BOYS #72 (MR) $4.99 DE
42 1567 1226 DEC110969 BOYS #63 (MR) $3.99 DE
43 1573 1213 OCT120985 MASKS #2 $3.99 DE
44 1575 1412 OCT121233-M SHADOWMAN #2 $3.99 VAL
45 1577 1234 JAN121021 BOYS #64 (MR) $3.99 DE
46 1583 993 FEB120905 BOYS #65 (MR) $4.99 DE
47 1587 1225 AUG121335-M X-O MANOWAR #6 $3.99 VAL
48 1595 1248 MAY121031 BOYS #68 (MR) $3.99 DE
49 1598 1239 MAR120936 BOYS #66 (MR) $3.99 DE
50 1604 1221 OCT120921 ADVENTURE TIME MARCELINE SCREAM QUEENS #6 $3.99 BOO
51 1605 1245 APR121020 BOYS #67 (MR) $3.99 DE
52 1610 1247 JUL120946 SHADOW #6 $3.99 DE
53 1619 1261 JUN121025 BOYS #69 (MR) $3.99 DE
54 1623 1275 JUL120952 BOYS #70 (MR) $3.99 DE
55 1624 1282 AUG120999 BOYS #71 (MR) $3.99 DE
56 1626 1258 SEP120933 ADVENTURE TIME MARCELINE SCREAM QUEENS #5 $3.99 BOO
57 1628 1756 NOV110720-M ARCHIE #629 (ARCHIE MEETS KISS PT 3 ) $2.99 ARC
58 1646 1283 JUN121326 HARBINGER #3 $3.99 VAL
59 1658 1824 DEC110813-M ARCHIE #630 (ARCHIE MEETS KISS PT 4 ) $2.99 ARC
60 1666 1306 JUL121259-M HARBINGER #4 $3.99 VAL
61 1695 1334 JUN121004 PATHFINDER #1 $3.99 DE
62 1724 1362 AUG121338-M ARCHER & ARMSTRONG #3 $3.99 VAL
63 1726 1367 JUL121261 ARCHER & ARMSTRONG #2 $3.99 VAL
64 1727 1376 AUG120983 SHADOW #7 $3.99 DE
65 1733 1374 AUG121332-M HARBINGER #5 $3.99 VAL
66 1739 1379 NOV121051-M VAMPIRELLA STRIKES #1 $3.99 DE
67 1744 1388 JUL121263 BLOODSHOT #3 $3.99 VAL
68 1746 1394 SEP121229 X-O MANOWAR #7 $3.99 VAL
69 1759 1410 AUG121339-M BLOODSHOT #4 $3.99 VAL
70 1769 1425 OCT121228-M ARCHER & ARMSTRONG #5 $3.99 VAL
71 1773 1433 OCT121239-M X-O MANOWAR #8 $3.99 VAL
72 1796 1463 AUG120971-M EVIL ERNIE #1 $3.99 DE
73 1801 3609 AUG120900-M FREELANCERS #1 $1.00 BOO
74 1811 1458 NOV110910-M GAME OF THRONES #5 (MR) $3.99 DE
75 1829 1491 SEP120987 SHADOW #8 $3.99 DE
76 1830 1502 JUL120936-M DAMSELS #1 $3.99 DE
77 1833 1497 SEP121225-M HARBINGER #6 $3.99 VAL
78 1850 1515 SEP121227-M ARCHER & ARMSTRONG #4 $3.99 VAL
79 1863 1523 DEC111021-M GAME OF THRONES #6 (MR) $3.99 DE
80 1869 1555 SEP120930-M BRAVEST WARRIORS #2 $3.99 BOO
81 1881 1543 SEP121223-M BLOODSHOT #5 $3.99 VAL
82 1882 1494 NOV110837 PEANUTS #1 $3.99 BOO
83 1883 1435 JUL120796-M FASHION BEAST #1 (MR) $3.99 AVA
84 1920 1570 MAR128256-M THE SPIDER #1 $3.99 DE
85 1927 1586 OCT121235-M HARBINGER #7 $3.99 VAL
86 1950 1594 JAN120878-M CROSSED BADLANDS #1 (MR) $3.99 AVA
87 1952 1614 OCT121237-M BLOODSHOT #6 $3.99 VAL
88 1955 2007 FEB128088-M GFT ALICE IN WONDERLAND #1 (MR) $2.99 ZEN
89 1963 1621 FEB120976 GAME OF THRONES #7 (MR) $3.99 DE
90 1976 1540 JAN120883-M CROSSED BADLANDS #2 (MR) $3.99 AVA
91 2017 1405 JUL120951 SHADOW ANNUAL #1 $4.99 DE
92 2036 1729 MAY128105-M HYPERNATURALS #1 $3.99 BOO
93 2048 2081 JUL121310-M ROBYN HOOD #1 (MR) $2.99 ZEN
94 2050 1735 MAR120979 GAME OF THRONES #8 (MR) $3.99 DE
95 2056 1157 MAY121364-M GRIMM FAIRY TALES #75 (MR) $5.99 ZEN
96 2057 1759 APR128099-M PROPHECY #1 $3.99 DE
97 2060 1752 APR121054 GAME OF THRONES #9 (MR) $3.99 DE
98 2064 1757 NOV110886 LORD OF THE JUNGLE #2 (MR) $3.99 DE
99 2070 1707 DEC110942 PEANUTS #2 $3.99 BOO
100 2074 1781 SEP111004 WARLORD OF MARS DEJAH THORIS #9 (MR) $3.99 DE

TOP 100 NON-PREMIER GRAPHIC NOVELS
Based on Total Unit Sales of Products Invoiced in Calendar Year 2012

QTY
RANK
OVERALL
QTY
RANK
OVERALL
DOLLAR
RANK
ITEM CODE DESCRIPTION PRICE VENDOR
1 10 25 APR121232 LOEG III CENTURY #3 2009 (MR) $9.95 TOP
2 51 87 SEP120922 ADVENTURE TIME TP VOL 01 $14.99 BOO
3 57 59 JAN121022 BOYS TP VOL 10 BUTCHER BAKER CANDLESTICKMAKER (MR) $19.99 DE
4 63 70 APR121021 BOYS TP VOL 11 OVER THE HILL W/T SWORDS OF A THOUSAND MEN (M $19.99 DE
5 88 63 MAY121234 SCOTT PILGRIM COLOR HC VOL 01 (OF 6) $24.99 ONI
6 110 110 OCT120994 BOYS TP VOL 12 BLOODY DOORS OFF (MR) $19.99 DE
7 118 96 JAN128076 UNDERWATER WELDER GN $19.95 TOP
8 120 483 JUL121137 TOWER CHRONICLES GN VOL 01 (OF 4) GEISTHAWK $7.99 LEG
9 140 82 JAN121043 GAME OF THRONES HC GN VOL 01 (MR) $25.00 RAN
10 145 352 NOV111036 SAILOR MOON TP KODANSHA ED VOL 03 $10.99 RAN
11 149 349 FEB108442 SCOTT PILGRIM GN VOL 01 PRECIOUS LITTLE LIFE $11.99 ONI
12 162 244 DEC078191 BOYS TP VOL 01 NAME OF THE GAME (MR) $16.99 DE
13 167 416 DEC111121 SAILOR MOON TP KODANSHA ED VOL 04 $10.99 RAN
14 169 115 FEB100697 CROSSED TP VOL 01 (MR) $24.99 AVA
15 180 267 JAN120780 RACHEL RISING TP VOL 01 SHADOW OF DEATH $16.99 ABS
16 183 163 SEP110750 JIM HENSONS DARK CRYSTAL HC VOL 01 CREATION MYTHS $19.95 ARA
17 184 195 JAN120869 CROSSED TP VOL 03 PSYCHOPATH (MR) $19.99 AVA
18 189 133 AUG121236 SCOTT PILGRIM COLOR HC VOL 02 (OF 6) $24.99 ONI
19 195 637 DEC111231 NARUTO TP VOL 55 $9.99 VIZ
20 201 649 NOV111126 NARUTO TP VOL 54 $9.99 VIZ
21 215 687 FEB121183 NARUTO TP VOL 56 $9.99 VIZ
22 221 519 FEB121079 SAILOR MOON TP KODANSHA ED VOL 05 $10.99 RAN
23 227 288 NOV110815 IRREDEEMABLE TP VOL 08 $16.99 BOO
24 240 747 APR121262 NARUTO TP VOL 57 $9.99 VIZ
25 242 168 SEP110972 BOYS TP VOL 09 BIG RIDE (MR) $24.99 DE
26 251 556 JUL111150 SAILOR MOON TP KODANSHA ED VOL 01 $10.99 RAN
27 255 663 MAY111195 LOEG III CENTURY #2 1969 (MR) $9.95 TOP
28 264 1101 OCT110819 SONIC THE HEDGEHOG ARCHIVES TP VOL 17 $7.99 ARC
29 269 598 FEB108443 SCOTT PILGRIM GN VOL 02 VS THE WORLD $11.99 ONI
30 282 242 FEB100651 JOHNNY HOMICIDAL MANIAC DIRECTORS CUT SC $21.95 SLA
31 291 651 APR121134 SAILOR MOON TP KODANSHA ED VOL 06 $10.99 RAN
32 305 126 JUL110825 A TALE OF SAND HC $29.95 ARA
33 310 918 AUG121347 NARUTO TP VOL 59 $9.99 VIZ
34 312 929 JUN121344 NARUTO TP VOL 58 $9.99 VIZ
35 315 326 JUN120842 CROSSED WISH YOU WERE HERE TP VOL 01 (MR) $19.99 AVA
36 318 246 DEC111207 HARVEY PEKAR CLEVELAND HC $21.99 TOP
37 319 713 NOV110737 SONIC UNIVERSE TP VOL 02 30 YEARS LATER $11.99 ARC
38 329 439 MAR120860 IRREDEEMABLE TP VOL 09 $16.99 BOO
39 330 337 MAR120929 BARRY SONNENFELDS DINOSAURS VS ALIENS HC $19.99 DE
40 334 347 DEC073541 BOYS TP VOL 02 GET SOME (MR) $19.99 DE
41 339 1295 MAR120767 SONIC THE HEDGEHOG ARCHIVES TP VOL 18 $7.99 ARC
42 340 265 AUG121252-M CHARLES BURNS HIVE GN $21.95 RAN
43 341 1179 SEP121141 TOWER CHRONICLES GN VOL 02 (OF 4) GEISTHAWK $7.99 LEG
44 350 308 JUL121018-M HOBBIT TP $20.00 RAN
45 355 800 JUN121186 SAILOR MOON TP KODANSHA ED VOL 07 $10.99 RAN
46 358 726 MAR128109-M BONE COLOR ED SC VOL 01 OUT BONEVILLE $12.99 SCH
47 364 113 JUN111212-M HABIBI GN (MR) $35.00 RAN
48 373 717 JAN120832 ARCHIE MEETS KISS TP $12.99 ARC
49 378 902 MAY063495 GRIMM FAIRY TALES TP VOL 01 $15.99 ZEN
50 382 206 MAR121056 WALT DISNEY UNCLE SCROOGE HC VOL 01  POOR OLD MAN $28.99 FAN
51 383 533 STAR08102 SQUEE TP $15.95 SLA
52 386 365 JUN110885 CROSSED TP VOL 02 FAMILY VALUES (MR) $19.99 AVA
53 387 964 FEB121158 LOST DOGS GN (MR) $9.95 TOP
54 388 602 JUN121130 LOVE AND ROCKETS NEW STORIES TP VOL 05 $14.99 FAN
55 394 380 JUL110881 ALAN MOORE NEONOMICON TP (MR) $19.99 AVA
56 396 515 JUN120937 IRREDEEMABLE TP VOL 10 $16.99 BOO
57 406 1131 MAY121323 YU GI OH GX GN VOL 09 (OF 9) $9.99 VIZ
58 412 76 JUL121170 CHRIS WARE BUILDING STORIES HC $50.00 RAN
59 415 395 JAN121241 ATOMIC ROBO TP VOL 06 GHOST OF STATION X $18.95 RED
60 421 915 AUG121202 SAILOR MOON TP KODANSHA ED VOL 08 $10.99 RAN
61 426 924 JAN120845 SONIC THE HEDGEHOG SELECT TP VOL 05 $11.99 ARC
62 429 897 FEB108444 SCOTT PILGRIM GN VOL 03 INFINITE SADNESS $11.99 ONI
63 431 388 OCT091063 ATOMIC ROBO TP VOL 01 $18.95 RED
64 446 844 NOV111151 BLACK BUTLER TP VOL 08 $11.99 HAC
65 449 1228 NOV111125 BLEACH TP VOL 38 $9.99 VIZ
66 461 469 DEC110968 GARTH ENNIS JENNIFER BLOOD TP VOL 01 (MR) $19.99 DE
67 472 1262 JAN121283 BLEACH TP VOL 39 $9.99 VIZ
68 473 330 AUG120845 CROSSED TP VOL 04 BADLANDS (MR) $24.99 AVA
69 475 692 NOV111155 HIGH SCHOOL OF DEAD GN VOL 05 (MR) $13.99 HAC
70 477 475 FEB110945 BOYS TP VOL 08 HIGHLAND LADDIE (MR) $19.99 DE
71 499 500 AUG083939 BOYS TP VOL 03 GOOD FOR THE SOUL (MR) $19.99 DE
72 504 1017 FEB108445 SCOTT PILGRIM GN VOL 04 GETS IT TOGETHER $11.99 ONI
73 521 1357 APR121263 BLEACH TP VOL 42 $9.99 VIZ
74 525 1374 MAR121239 BLEACH TP VOL 40 $9.99 VIZ
75 526 976 FEB121204 BLACK BUTLER TP VOL 09 $11.99 HAC
76 531 862 JUN121162 AMULET SC VOL 05 PRINCE OF THE ELVES $12.99 SCH
77 534 517 DEC111153 SIXTH GUN TP VOL 03 $19.99 ONI
78 538 677 SEP120729 RACHEL RISING TP VOL 02 FEAR NO MALUS $16.99 ABS
79 541 1573 FEB094465 LOEG III CENTURY #1 1910 (MR) $7.95 TOP
80 542 172 FEB042691 FROM HELL TP (MR) $35.00 TOP
81 543 1397 MAR121240 BLEACH TP VOL 41 $9.99 VIZ
82 544 1392 APR121264 BLEACH TP VOL 43 $9.99 VIZ
83 547 1104 DEC110824 MEGA MAN TP VOL 02 TIME KEEPS SLIPPING $11.99 ARC
84 557 810 FEB121207 HIGH SCHOOL OF DEAD GN VOL 06 (MR) $13.99 HAC
85 566 1420 MAY121325 BLEACH TP VOL 44 $9.99 VIZ
86 575 1105 SEP111140 SAILOR MOON TP KODANSHA ED VOL 02 $10.99 RAN
87 581 1438 MAY121326 BLEACH TP VOL 45 $9.99 VIZ
88 583 1127 FEB108446 SCOTT PILGRIM GN VOL 05 VS THE UNIVERSE $11.99 ONI
89 585 720 JAN120944 INCORRUPTIBLE TP VOL 06 $16.99 BOO
90 595 1454 SEP121242 YU GI OH ZEXAL GN VOL 02 $9.99 VIZ
91 598 584 MAY090788 BOYS TP VOL 04 WE GOTTA GO NOW (MR) $19.99 DE
92 600 424 FEB121067 ARE YOU MY MOTHER A COMIC DRAMA HC $22.00 HOU
93 609 488 AUG111018 HARK A VAGRANT HC (MR) $19.95 DRA
94 613 1491 AUG121350 BLEACH TP VOL 50 $9.99 VIZ
95 615 378 MAY090647 MOUSE GUARD HC VOL 02 WINTER 1152 W/ DUST JACKET $24.95 ARA
96 617 1486 OCT121241 X-O MANOWAR (ONGOING) TP VOL 01 BY THE SWORD $9.99 VAL
97 622 761 MAY120949 INCORRUPTIBLE TP VOL 07 $16.99 BOO
98 623 600 SEP100958 BOYS TP VOL 07 THE INNOCENTS (MR) $19.99 DE
99 627 1510 AUG121351 BLEACH TP VOL 51 $9.99 VIZ
100 628 1509 JUL121266 BLEACH TP VOL 48 $9.99 VIZ

This information may not be reproduced in any format without the express permission of Diamond Comic Distributors.

How does Diamond calculate the charts? It all starts at the comic book shop.

Data for Diamond’s sales charts – which include the monthly market shares and all top product charts – are compiled by Diamond Comic Distributors from a universe of over 3,500 accounts, comprised of comic book specialty shops and other merchant stores and buyers. The shops are primarily located in North America, with a percentage of sales also to international stores and buyers located throughout the world. The account base includes not only brick-and-mortar comic book specialty shops, but also Internet stores, chain stores, and other specialty stores.

Unit and dollars sales are calculated based upon orders invoiced and shipped to Diamond accounts during any given month, minus any copies that are distributed free of cost.

About the Diamond Sales Index: The Sales Index of selected monthly Best Seller Charts is presented as a comparative tool for retailers and publishers. It presents Diamond’s monthly sales for individual titles in relation to Diamond’s total sales for the issue of DC Comics' monthly Batman comic book. (Batman is used as the control title – with a value of 100 – because sales of Batman generally remain stable.) This allows for easy comparison to other titles and helps retailers gauge their orders for all other titles. This formula is only a guide, other factors may impact a titles’ ability to sell in certain locations and clientele.